Civic Thought After the Midterms
By Benjamin Storey and Jenna Silber Storey
November 12, 2026
The results of last week’s state elections have raised questions about the future of the schools of civic thought that have been recently created at public universities. This is especially true in Texas, Ohio, Arizona, Iowa, and North Carolina, which saw significant political shifts.
We’ve long tracked these schools’ development, and over the last week have checked in with most of their leaders. Consideration of the particular facts of their political and institutional landscapes can provide a helpful reality check on the gloomy or giddy “vibes” many are feeling after the election. While worries about their future are not completely unfounded, there are serious reasons to have confidence in the stability of these schools and their potential for continuing growth.
First, the deans, directors, and faculty of the frontrunners among these schools have rapidly created significant institutional assets by building excellent programs. Those schools that have established a significant body of faculty—numbering 65 at the University of Florida’s Hamilton Center, 40 at the University of Texas at Austin’s School of Civic Leadership, 30 at the University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill’s School of Civic Life and Leadership, 27 at Arizona State’s School of Civic and Economic Thought and Leadership (SCETL), and 25 at Ohio State’s Salmon P. Chase Center—are in a different situation than fledgling schools such as University of Iowa’s Center for Intellectual Freedom, which has yet to install a permanent director.
Schools of civic thought that have been operating for five or more semesters have already attracted thousands of students to their classrooms and hundreds of students to new majors. They have created a significant hiring boom in the otherwise declining sector of the humanities and social sciences. And they have given smart administrators something of great value: a serious academic project that can be loved by the broad group of Americans who have lost trust in the direction of the academy over the last decade.
Second, the most direct way that electoral shifts will affect these schools is through the composition of state boards of regents and trustees. Higher education board members typically have staggered, fixed-term appointments, so the direction of the board is unlikely to change direction overnight. At the University of Texas at Austin, for example, 6 of the 9 Regents appointed by Governor Greg Abbott will remain in place for the next two years, and 3 have terms that stretch through 2031. Moreover, the Texas State Senate, still Republican-dominated, must approve all candidates to the board.
Governors seeking to remain in office in states that retain strong conservative leanings although they have rejected Trump-aligned candidates should be motivated to appoint regents who can work across the political aisle. Stabilizing their state’s institutional assets in higher education should be a priority. They can do so by rolling back some of the more outrageous measures of the last several years, such as divisive concept bans, while preserving programs that are academically serious and popular with students and their families.
Third, academic work requires the long view, and institutional protections for it are designed accordingly. Schools of civic thought are largely composed of tenured and tenure-track faculty, some of whom occupy endowed chairs; these faculty enjoy the same significant job protections as faculty in other departments. In some states, this includes the right of tenure-track faculty to seek tenure, and the stipulation that if an academic unit is eliminated, faculty are transferred to other departments, not dismissed.
Stepping back to look at the big picture, though, we should remember that political actions should only have a targeted and limited influence on university offerings. As we’ve argued, trustees, regents, and state legislators may sometimes need to open space for new academic projects, given that the hiring and incentive structures of higher education strongly encourage path dependency. But once that space is opened, those academic projects need to prove themselves by the standards of compelling teaching and insightful scholarship.
That’s why Hollis Robbins is right to point out that the favor of state legislatures for one’s academic efforts is a mixed blessing, and that a good long-term strategy for programmatic stability is for civic thought faculty to continue making common cause with other humanists and social scientists who share their sense of the importance of asking open-ended fundamental questions, and even to seek unconventional allies in programs such as Black Studies when possible. As Jacob Bruggeman, assistant professor in Ohio State’s Salmon P. Chase Center writes, in the age of AI, “demand for rigorous humanities courses built on close reading and in class debate will continue to grow. University leadership know that civic centers, by our interdisciplinary and organizational flexibility, are well-positioned to offer such courses.”
To gain more insight into the experience of faculty who teach in these programs, one can listen to a conversation CFAU’s Jenna Silber Storey recently hosted with three of their faculty members: Daniel DiSalvo (University of North Carolina), Stéphane Lavertu (Ohio State University), and Karen Taliaferro (University of Florida).
All three point out that the intellectual pluralism of these schools makes them attractive to students and faculty. As DiSalvo observes, the UNC’s School of Civic Life and Leadership “is probably one of the more intellectually diverse units I’ve ever seen in higher education.” Taliaferro agrees, adding that “There are a lot of points of friction [among faculty at the UF Hamilton Center], but it’s productive friction.” Lavertu notes, too, that these schools are animated by a mission gives distinct purpose to their pluralism: “A core part of our mission is forming citizens and leaders for a free society. It is about intellectual diversity but it’s also first and foremost about creating citizens who can sustain this republic.”
So, while last week’s political shift might put some wind in the sails of opponents of these programs, higher education leaders who have worked through electoral changes in the past, such as Arizona State University President Michael Crow, know that these schools can be put on firm bipartisan footing. The University of Virginia has wisely perceived this possibility, hiring Paul Carrese, the founding director of ASU’s SCETL, to join in spearheading an expansion of the Program on Constitutionalism and Democracy even after the state elected a Democratic governor last year.
If some leaders bow to immediate political pressure and undermine the schools of civic thought their campuses host, they will be foregoing the chance to embrace an innovation that is both academically rigorous and broadly popular, doing their universities no favors in the long run.
